top of page
Search

THE ETHICS OF SWEATSHOPS

jananijanakiraman03
11 minutes ago
2 min read

If you were keeping up with my previous blogs, you would know that in the last one I briefly touched upon the topic of sweatshops. For a little background, sweatshops are arguably most primarily expanded by globalization, though they did exist before globalization. Sweatshops are most popular in less-developed countries, but that is not always the case. China, for example, has hundreds of sweatshops in their more rural areas, despite China being quite the developed country. In any case, it is clear that sweatshops are often found in the most economically underdeveloped areas, if not always countries. 

I’m sure that when we all hear about sweatshops, many are quick to jump to the notion that they must be abolished. Though sweatshops in itself are unethical, and many would agree that the world is a better place without them, is just getting rid of them really the best idea?

In my previous blog, I found evidence from the Constitutional Rights Foundation which found that despite the fact that sweatshop workers are inhumanely treated with unfair wages, many of them are vehemently against the removal of sweatshops. To them, the sweatshops keep them out of poverty; without the sweatshops, they would have no income whatsoever. 

So, what’s the answer? If we remove sweatshops, we subject the workers to extreme poverty, and potentially death. On the other hand, is it not unethical to keep the sweatshops? Some may argue that keeping sweatshops in this case may in fact be morally good, as the other scenario leads to a worse outcome for the greater good (the utilitarian perspective). The Kantian perspective, though, would argue that we should get rid of sweatshops, as the very act of more developed countries inhumane exploiting underdeveloped countries is wrong, and people are not a means to an end. 

However, I think that the solution isn’t so black and white. Rather than simply going for the deontologist or utilitarian approach, I argue that we should go for the sweet spot right in the middle. Yes, sweatshops do need to be removed, BUT we must put a proper framework into place before doing so. There are a myriad of solutions that have been proposed, with a very common one being automated manufacturing. Automation, however, is a very debated issue, but many do argue that it is inevitable. So, if automation does replace the work that sweatshop workers do, what can we do for the workers? Personally, I would propose a high-skill education regimen for all that gives every citizen an opportunity to now work in less replaceable jobs. Additionally, a stronger skill-set means that the citizens would never have to rely on sweatshops for an income again. However, there are hundreds of different solutions out there that different economists and politicians have proposed. Despite those solutions, do you have any solutions?

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page